If you have clay, you can make hands out of clay, cover it with thin plastic, and do 3-5 layers of papier mache with heavy paper. You will probably have to cut them off the clay and papier mache them back together.

Cardboard Single Hand
cardboard single hand

Cardboard Double Hand
cardboard double hand

See Masque of the Five Senses

Thumbnail Sketches
Thumbnail Photos

Puppeteers' Cooperative Home Page